Which proof do you need?
Before a publication goes to final production, there are usually several opportunities to check that everything is looking, reading and functioning as it should.
But a proof isn't simply a smaller version of the finished job. Different proofing methods are designed to answer different questions.
Do the pages flow correctly?
Is the colour right?
Are the folds going where they should?
Does that image crossing the gutter actually line up?
Will the finished book look the way you expect?
The right proof depends on what you need to check, as well as the printing process, paper, binding and finishing involved.
At inc., we can arrange and manage different proofing options and help you decide which is appropriate for your project.
PDF soft proof of the Inc Zine
Soft proofs
A soft proof is a digital PDF proof generated through the printer's prepress workflow. You may also hear these referred to as digital proofs.
Soft proofs are primarily used to check content and structure before production.
They allow you to check things such as:
Text and spelling
Page order
Pagination
Image placement
Layout
Fonts
Imposition
General file integrity
Some issues caused by incorrect transparency or font settings
Because these files have been processed through the printer's prepress system, they can also highlight technical problems that may not be obvious in the original artwork.
Soft proofs are often supplied at a lower resolution to keep file sizes manageable.
What they aren't: a reliable representation of final colour. What you see on screen can vary depending on your monitor, display settings and viewing conditions.
Epsom Contract proofs for the Botanical Bingo Game Offset Print
Epsom contract proofs
A contract proof is a physical colour proof produced to provide a reference for colour reproduction before the full print run.
An Epsom proofing system may be used to produce these proofs, depending on the printer and production process.
They allow you to assess colour and image reproduction on a physical sheet rather than relying solely on your screen.
Contract proofs include the colour bar and the files colour output settings such as fogra ICC profiles.
Contract proofs can be particularly useful when colour accuracy is important, but they are not necessarily produced using the exact printing process, inks and paper that will be used for the final job.
Indigo printer colour proofs
An HP Indigo colour proof is another physical proofing option that can be used to assess colour and image reproduction before production.
As with other contract proofing methods, the purpose is to provide a physical colour reference and identify potential issues before committing to the full print run.
The suitability of an Indigo proof depends on the project and the final printing process, so we'll advise on the most appropriate option.
Wet proofs for The Terrible Boredom of Paradise book by Derek Henderson
Wet proofs
A wet proof is produced using the actual printing process, inks and paper intended for the final production run.
This makes it the most accurate type of proof when you need to assess how the final combination of paper, ink and printing process will behave.
Wet proofs allow you to check:
Colour
Image reproduction
Paper
Print quality
Registration
Overall appearance
They are more expensive than other proofing methods because the actual production process needs to be set up and run.
For projects where colour, paper or image reproduction is particularly critical, a wet proof can provide valuable reassurance before the full production run.
A wet proof is sometimes referred to as a scatter proof, particularly where selected pages or sheets are produced rather than the entire publication.
Ozalid proofs for New Wheels for Granny P, offset printed, section sewn children’s book.
Ozalids / F&Gs / running sheets
An ozalid, also commonly referred to as an F&G (folded and gathered) or running sheet, is a physical proof used primarily to check the structure and content of a publication, rather than colour.
The sheets are produced, folded, gathered and trimmed so you can physically work through the publication as it will come together before binding.
They're particularly useful for checking:
Page order and pagination
Imposition
Section sequence
Gatefolds and fold-outs
Folding direction
Crossover images
Gutter clearances
Content close to the binding
Inserts and tip-ins
Overall physical structure
Ozalids are not colour proofs. Their purpose is to make sure the publication is physically working before it proceeds further into production.
Advance mock ups for various books
Book mock up
A book mock-up is a physical, unprinted version of the finished book, produced to the full extent and on the actual stocks specified for the project.
The mock-up is bound and sewn, allowing you to assess the physical characteristics of the finished publication before committing to print.
It can be used to check:
Overall size and proportions
Page count and thickness
Paper stocks and their interaction
Binding and sewing
Cover construction
Spine width
Fold-outs and gatefolds
Inserts and other structural elements
How the book feels and handles as a physical object
Because there is no printing, a mock-up is not a colour or content proof. Its purpose is to test the physical construction and materials of the book before production.
Binding and finishing proofs for the Unmaking of book by Kowtow
So, which proof do you need?
There isn't one proof that's right for every project. Here’s a summary of what each type of proof is primarily used to check.
Soft proof: Content, layout, pagination and technical issues
Epson contract proof: Physical colour reference
Indigo colour proof: Physical colour and image reproduction
Wet proof: Final colour, paper, ink and print process
Ozalid / F&G / running sheet: Pagination, imposition, folding and physical structure
Book mock-up: Physical construction, materials, binding and overall extent
The right choice depends on what you're printing and what you need to know before production.
A straightforward publication may only require a soft proof. A colour-critical art book printed on a specialist paper may warrant a physical colour proof or wet proof. A complex casebound book with gatefolds, inserts and multiple sections may benefit from an ozalid or F&Gs to check the physical construction.
Need help choosing?
That's where we come in.
We can advise on the appropriate proofing method for your project, taking into account the printing process, paper, binding, finishing and the things that matter most to you.
Because finding a problem before the print run is considerably easier than finding it after 500 copies have been printed.
Talk to inc. about proofing for your next print project.